Monday, February 11, 2008

How close to 36% of American families are below a realistic poverty line?


How close to 36% of American families are below a realistic poverty line?

The 50 percentile American family income in 2005 was $61,032. (http://www.census.gov/hhes/www/income/data/historical/families/ Table F-3, Mean Family Income, All Races)

The "minimum needs" table (3-2) on p.44 of the 2001 book Raise the Floor maps out a minimum needs line for a family of three at $45,476 in 2012 dollars -- including $8,786 cost of medical insurance. * The Raise minimum needs line is computed by totaling up a comprehensive list of needs -- not the half-century old federal formula that multiplies three times the cost of an emergency food budget (dried beans only please; no expensive canned!).

(Raise provides extensive explanations for its minimum needs parameters in Appendix B -- its tables cite Solutions for Progress. Average family size is 3.13 persons.)

The difference between second and third quintile average family incomes ($37,556 and $61,032) runs approximately $1,200/percentile. So, adding about $6,000 to $37,556 (the 30 percentile mark -- the second quintle mean) gets us to Raise's minimum needs line -- demarking 36% of American families below minimum needs if they have to buy their own health insurance and 29% if they do -- and excluding government helps like food stamps.

[* "Raise's" tables allot $3,000 to yearly medical expenses for a family of three even if insured.]

Wednesday, February 6, 2008

REVERSE Ponzi schemes: S.S. and Medicare

Just as S.S. retirement benefits constitute a REVERSE Ponzi scheme because the doubling of per-person income over every two generations means your grandkids can soak their grandkids for even more than you are soaking yours for (the sucker generation may be the one destroyed by the alien invasion)...

...the medical REVERSE Ponzi is even more spectacular because scientific knowledge doubles every decade (!) and presumably medical knowledge keeps up something like the same pace (the sucker generation may be the one in which all diseases are eliminated).

Ergo, somebody has to pay for the medical miracle show. Luckily, by 2080 -- almost FOUR generations out -- average income should have almost quadrupled while medical care's share of GDP has only tripled (according to the above chart: meaning care in 2080 cost may twelve times as much in absolute terms (4 X 3) per-person.

Today -- 2008 -- medical care's share of GDP is 3X what it was in 1968 while average income has jumped 2X: making per-person care cost 6 times what we used to spend in absolute terms: anybody want to turn back that clock?

PS. The real crisis is that 25% of American workers now earn less in real terms than LBJ's 1968 minimum wage -- and that a 25% of Americans now live below a real poverty line (not the phony poverty line computed solely as multiple of the cheapest nutrition), up from 15% in 1968 -- after that doubling of average income over two generations. Labor market, labor market, labor market -- a completely unbalanced in management's favor American labor market: that should be the signature economic issue on today's progressives' lips; not some imaginary non-problem at the end of the century.

Tuesday, February 5, 2008

Mandate SUBSIDES are indistinguishable from VOUCHERS (remember vouchers?)

If we absolutely must base universal coverage on private insurance: wouldn't VOUCHERS (remember vouchers) be more practical than mandates?

If you don't get a voucher you really deserve one in of your peculiar economic circumstance (at X income level) at least you are not forced to pay for something you cannot afford; you may just land back in the old ER -- fewer mandate suicides.
***
Come to think of it: SUBSIDES for low-income mandatees are indistinguishable from VOCHERS -- both tax paid.

If the REAL poverty line (as the informed are aware -- sort of as the informed were aware the earth is round before Columbus) is more like $40,000/yr for a family of four -- and median family income is tragically something like $55,000/hr -- and we want to be very careful that mandates do not put some families into impossible binds (I would argue life's little complications make that undoable): we may plausibly need to give as much as 100% subsidy for up 1 1/2 X the real poverty line (approx. median family income)?

The majority of families would probably get some level of subsidy -- equivalent to a means tested vouchers. Obama and Hill are half way to vouchers already!
***
Basically, mandates make the issue about HOW we achieve UHC -- advantage Repubs: "garnishing wages!?" Vouchers have the Dem advantage of being the Repubs' eternal answer for everything -- how can they object to mandates as the HOW part of UHC?

Sunday, February 3, 2008

Red shifting minimum wage?

Does the concept of "red shift" suggest itself?

Ike's 1956 minimum wage: $7.93/hr ($1.00/hr adjusted)
at 40% of today's average income.

LBJ's 1968 minimum wage: $9.91/hr ($1.60/hr adjusted
at 50% of today's average income.
Nixon's 1974 minimum wage: $8.75/hr ($2.00/hr adjusted)
at 60% of today's average income.



G.H.W.'s 1981 minimum wage: $6.72 ($4.25/hr adjusted)
at 70% of today's average income.
Bill's 1997 minimum wage: $6.92/hr ($5.15/hr adjusted)
at 90% of today's average income.
Dem's 2009 minimum raise: $7.00/hr? ($7.25/hr adjusted)
at 103% of today's average income?


Saturday, February 2, 2008

Why American labor slept

Regardless of government policy (had there been no Reagan) America's (uniquely) one-sided labor market -- disappearing unions and naive and complacent American labor -- would have brought on catastrophic inequality anyway (so catastrophic, if you live under 50 percentile income, that "inequality" seems a weak, under-descriptive term).

Naive and complacent labor is the root of all American inequality (or great wage depression) -- lack of simple understanding of relentless labor market squeeze that has to be deliberately met. America -- having a much better labor history than Europe -- has not developed the same over-defensive labor ethic that Europe has developed. We instead have our pioneer cult of the self-reliant individual. Ironically this leads our labor force to NOT take care of itself in the market place but to just trust unseen forces to fairly set labor's price. The latter might be a good angle to sell properly taking care of themselves to Americans once they wake up to the prosperity they (uniquely) have been missing out on.

American's might wake up if their media ever gets around to informing them that a true poverty scale (not one made up of a multiple of cheap meals) might show 25% of Americans living below the poverty line -- up from 15% in LBJ's era; double the average income since. They might also wake up of the media ever informed them that 25% of our workforce is now earning less than LBJ's $9.90/hr minimum wage, ditto doubled income. The media itself might wake up if progressives ever make enough stink over these two all telling stats.

Friday, February 1, 2008

How health mandates could land more in the ER

Imagine a future in which families were mandated to buy a health plan -- some purchase the one with the $10,000 deductible (the cheapest legal option?) -- okay; they have obeyed the law -- but now those families end up in the emergency room MORE OFTEN, instead going to their family doctor's office, because they were forced to use up their family doctor money buying what Obama correctly calls "home insurance."

Subsidies tend to be set at a multiple of what -- in reality -- should be a doubled fed poverty line: $20,000 a year for a family of four (the official line based on three times the price of an emergency diet). $40,000/yr is more like the -- real -- barely above poverty line for a family of four, while $55,000/yr is roughly median family income these days. Most families are not far from poverty -- though their numbers might sound just fine -- as med insurance climbs and climbs. Forcing rising premiums down the throats of families with shrinking real world incomes is flirting with disaster in many cases -- and would impose disaster outright upon many hanging by a thread families.

I really believe our academic liberals have much trouble envisioning the existences of anyone below 50 percentile income -- why you almost never hear Dem candidates so much as mention the average Americans' most desperate economic need, massive re-unionization -- nor criticize a ridiculous minimum wage raise that may end up nearly a dollar below 1956's minimum wage ($7.93 adjusted) in real 2009 buying power -- and here we go again.

Tuesday, January 22, 2008

Want Medicare When Old: Why Afraid Now?

How to sell Medicare-for-all to worriers:
"You plan to using Medicare in the future when you expect to need health care the most -- in your old age, when you will be most vulnerable -- why be afraid of it now?

If people wish to continue their current coverage, we can tell them we have no problem with their paying more for health care. Maybe individuals or consumers could be relieved of the tax that supports Medicare if they pay for private care. I expect the cost difference would convert them soon.

Medicare-for-all would end today's coverage DISCRIMINATION between Medicaid which covers the poor -- LBJ's ORIGINAL IDEA -- poorly, with often starkly lower fees and Medicare which covers the old (who vote in large numbers) quite adequately. If we suffered Medicaid-for-all today, doctors would all be leaving for Canada.

I cannot think of anything that might -- I may be wrong; I am not sure -- put fence-sitting voters off even more than even Hil's 1994 proposal to take away their current health schemes and replace same with an unknown, than proposing to force mandates on them. If anything, mandate based coverage would spark more focused opposition because it would be a more defined threat (a.k.a., target).

Monday, January 21, 2008

Does A Low Minimum Wage CUT Demand At Min/Wg Businesses?!

Late thought on the minimum wage which shows how easy it could be to pay poor Americans much more:
if hiking the minimum wage redirects demand toward businesses that pay the minimum wage because they tend to serve a lower income clientele: does that mean that NOT hiking the minimum wage to keep up with inflation -- or growing average income -- would actually tend to CUT demand (over time) at minimum wage businesses?

Even without the "redirecting demand to their own businesses" phenom', what would actually take place on that old eco 101 price/demand chart
when the min/wg is raised is: the same thing that would have happened without the wage hike: the demand curve would keep inching up (nominally) in step with inflation raises to employees across the economy -- while the price curve crept up respectfully behind, afraid to alienate consumers.

American workers have got to shake loose from the Newt Gingriches and their homeopathic (as in unscientific and always proved wrong by experience) unfettered-market theories.

When Black People Finally Got On The Up Escalator...

As one of my brothers famously put it: "When black people finally [in late 60s, early 70s] got on the up [economic] escalator, it started going down for everybody."

Imagine if King knew that 40 years after his last sermon, the minimum wage would be almost $4/hr lower than the 1968 minimum wage ($9.50/hr*) in real buying power -- that 25% of Americans would be living below a reality based poverty line based on a market basket of goods and services (not three times the price of the cheapest possible food basket which is the federal line), up from 15% in poverty back then...

...and that virtually every progressive news and comment outlet would perpetually parrot the decades obsolete official poverty line -- and never alert the people to the crazy increase in poverty as average income doubled...

...and that most every liberal and conservative (white? -- I have nothing against white people, having 5 Irish grandparents counting my mother's stepmother) commentator and pol would be much more obsessed with a war they are forced to watch on television that cost 1000 American maimed and 1000 killed a year than 75 million Americans are unable climb out of their economic sinkholes (wonder how many American lives that costs every year) -- that most (white?) progressives can even think that the so-called war even can even be spoken of in the same breath as the "Great Wage Depression"?

Don't ask me; ask King.

Such unimaginable economic regression (repression?) could lead to violence plagued housing projects because economically desperate drug dealing gangs had formed -- while minimum wage jobs were filled by even more desperate immigrants willing to work for 1939ish minimum wages ($4.50/hr w/no tax). Wouldn't that be positively unimaginable -- to King?

[ * $1.60/hr/1968 adjusts to $9.49/hr/2007 --

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

The "Nixon Stimulus": Avoid Recession?

Introducing the "Nixon stimulus":

My stimulus of preference would be shifting income to people who will spend more (save less) via a sizable jump in the minimum wage. There should be plenty of headroom for a minimum wage jump since today's federal minimum wage is several dollars below LBJ's, 1968, minimum wage of $9.50/hr ($380/wk, adjusted -- at 50% of today's average income, yet).

Dick Nixon (far left winger by many contemporary Democrat's standards?) one-jumped the minimum from $7.50/hr (it had fallen $2!) to $8.50/hr in 1974 (at 60% of today's average income, yet). Of course this was the same Nixon who instituted federal block grants to the states (another current stimulus proposal), so he may be too much of a radical for contemporary Democrats to emulate.

Serial-jumping the minimum wage from $5.15/hr to $12.50/hr ($500/wk!), over as many years as you wish, would add all of 3.5% to the cost of GDP output (and presumably no more direct inflation, not counting other wages pushed up) -- about how much we grow every couple of years -- and could wipe out poverty (and most crime?).

Last time I looked, John Edwards proposed hiking the minimum in serial steps to $9.50/hr by 2012 -- nominally the same as LBJs minimum of 1968. But inflation may cut Edward's minimum by as much as 20%, landing us back between Eisenhower's minimum ($7.50/hr) and Nixon's minimum ($8.50/hr -- at more than double 1968's average income, yet) -- typical contemporary progressive proposal.

Why not give the lowest paid, longest suffering American workers a double break from inflation: why not index Edwards' projected minimum wage target ($9.50/hr), and all the serial steps in between, for inflation, so that by 2012, their wages might actually catch up with 1968?

If LBJ had only indexed his minimum wage for inflation we might have no poverty in this country today (certainly on ghetto projects infested with drug dealing, mostly out of desperation, gangs): a ratchet effect might have boosted the constant-dollar minimum wage by at least occasional jumps to keep pace with average income growth. If any two people could earn $1000/wk doing anything, how much poverty could there be (after doubling the average income of LBJ's time)?

Tuesday, January 15, 2008

John Edwards' -- Actually -- Minimal Minimum Wage Proposal

LBJ's, 1968, minimum wage was $9.50/hr, adjusted for inflation -- at 50% (!) of today's per capita income no less (productivity doubles every 40 years).

Edwards', (promised) 2012, minimum wage of $9.50/hr, adjusted for likely inflation should be worth 15+% less: or about $8/hr -- a big fifty cents more than Eisenhower's, 1956, minimum wage which was $7.50/hr, adjusted for inflation -- at 40% (!) of today's per capita income no less.

Just to give the latter per capita income some perspective: at 40% of today's average income our house used to eat many varieties of macaroni for dinner, along with hamburger helper -- not because we were so poor, but because that was the level people lived at then.

It cause all of 3.5% to the cost of GDP output -- and add the same 3.5% to direct inflation -- to jump the minimum wage all the way from $5.15/hr to $12.50/hr -- spread over a couple or three years as you please.

Dick Nixon, jumped the minimum wage from $6.50/hr (it fallen far back, as it so often does) to $8.50/hr, in today's money, in one shot.

The scheduled Democrat minimum wage raise projected to reach all of $7.25/hr, by 2009, may actually lowball Eisenhower's minimum wage by .50/hr, by the time inflation takes its toll.

What more can I say?

Saturday, January 12, 2008

Both Sides (Israelis & Palestinians) Have Their Grievances?!

Both sides have their grievances? That's like saying that both sides had their grievances when Germany invaded France -- only Israel's version of "Germany" was territory already absconded for their victims version of "France", 60 years earlier.

The greatest terrorist threat to the United States is Israelo-facism -- the terrorism launched against us in revenge for what is seen as the actions of America's virtual 51st state.

If it looks like a duck: Israelis look like most of us, talk the same English, walk the same Western life style and the other half of their ethnic group actually ARE ducks (not to mention ex-ducks living Israel-side). If the other half of their ethnic group were New Zealanders, does anybody think they would possess all those shiny F-16s, etc.

As long as we are going to take the credit for Israelo-facism whether or not we are to blame, we have a compelling motive to come down hard on our "little brother" to end the occupation of Islamic land -- totally. 10% of Israel's rich population has no compelling need move in on the poor land next door -- and the "first" 50 states don't need to trade anymore skyscrapers for settlements.

Friday, January 11, 2008

S.S. Trust Fund Never Be Totally Depleted: Why -- Reverse Ponzi Scheme S.S.

There is no reason for people in 2041 to take a 25% hit: the income tax that has been "cashing" government owned bonds will simply be reduced by the same proportion that the payroll tax (FICA) will be raised and the party will go on. The clunkiness will simply go out of clunky retirement collections.

The only sensible reason to have a Trust Fund for S.S. is to bridge a temporary shortfall in the payroll tax stream, until Congress raises it a mite (happened twice so far) -- meaning a (say 5 year) bridge should be maintained permanently anyway -- meaning FICA should take over even before the Trust Fund is completely depleted.
***************
S.S. is basically a reverse Ponzi scheme in which each generation gets more than it paid in because of economic growth: if you start your work career at $50,000/yr, you should end doing $100,000 doing equivalent work, 40 years later.

I am sure the wages of my old Teamster buddies back in 804 kept up with per capita growth since I left them in 1970 (back problems). They had just gotten an increase of $18/wk over 3 years from a base of $120/wk ($95 increase on $640/wk in 2007 dollars). They recently raised their defined retirement benefit from $3300/mo to 3600/mo: to more then they were making in wages 38 years ago!

Meantime Chicago cabdrivers now earn half what they earned when I started there 28 years ago (wouldn't catch me cabbing in Chicago now): one 30 cent mileage raise between 1981 and 1997 -- at which 1990 midpoint Chicago began adding 40% more cabs (still adding) while cutting the business seemingly in half with trains to both airports and open limo licenses (the cream) and finally (the coup de grace) free trolleys between all the hot spots downtown (the bread and butter).

The difference between the two segments of labor is bargaining muscle, nothing else -- in the Teamsters supplied by excess testosterone. I remember our local president, Ron Carey, calling a "strike" shouting "I'm not saying there's a dollar there". There was, the very next day: $18/wk instead of only $17. I had the feeling as he called the strike it was just to get strike out of these very militant guys' systems -- with a wink and an nod from management.

Sector-wide labor agreements (as practiced around the OECD world) dispel with the need for testosterone overload and make things easier for employers (around the OECD world) too -- like the minimum wage really does by raising everybody's costs the same amount at the same time. Sector-wide is really the soft solution to the race to the bottom state side.

Get wages back to LBJ era distribution at today's doubled average income and all our poverty and S.S. problems would go away.

Thursday, January 10, 2008

Why I -- Now -- Believe

I was always skeptical about global warming until I viewed a recent Discovery Channel program on global dimming (indisputable and apparently slows global warming) -- which suddenly made perfect sense of it all.

I never worried much about the dangers of global warming until I watched a recent History Channel show on how easily global warming could switch over to global freezing by melting fresh water icebergs which in turn could block the north Atlantic warm water current -- a potential civilization breaking catastrophe.

I never realized until I read a 9/16, NY Times article by the authors of the book Freakanomics that Jane Fonda would be the chief culprit in bringing on global freezing, because of her 1979 movie "The China Syndrome" which frightened America away from switching from fossil fuel to nuclear power. :-)